Commission vs Flat Fee Online Ordering: The Real Maths

If you sell through a delivery app, you pay a percentage of every order. If you sell through your own ordering website, you pay a subscription and card processing fees. Which is cheaper depends on your sales, and the gap is usually bigger than owners expect.
This post is for restaurant owners who want the commission vs flat fee online ordering comparison in actual dollars. We work through one example in full, weekly, monthly and yearly, include card fees on both sides where they apply, and finish with the cases where a delivery app is still the better call. FoodFlick publishes this guide, so we use its own prices and flag where the maths favours something else.
What is the setup for this example?
Everything below is an illustration. Swap in your own figures.
Online sales: $5,000 a week.
Average order: $50, so 100 orders a week.
Marketplace commission: 25% of the order subtotal. This matches DoorDash's published Plus delivery rate.
Direct card fees: 2.9% + $0.30 per order, Stripe's published standard US rate for domestic cards.
Flat-fee software: $59 a month, the FoodFlick Starter price. Annual payment takes 10% off, which we leave out to keep things simple.
A month is 52 weeks divided by 12, or 4.33 weeks.
What do delivery apps charge?
DoorDash's merchant pricing lists Marketplace commission of 15% (Basic), 25% (Plus) and 30% (Premier) on delivery orders, and 6% on pickup. It states that the commission covers card processing on Marketplace orders. Other apps in other countries charge different rates and may add fees for ads or promotions. See our delivery app fees pages for each one.
What does 25% commission cost per week, month and year?
Period | Calculation | Commission |
|---|---|---|
Per order | $50 x 25% | $12.50 |
Per week | $5,000 x 25% | $1,250 |
Per month | $1,250 x 4.33 | about $5,417 |
Per year | $1,250 x 52 | $65,000 |
Note that a week is not a quarter of a month: multiply weekly figures by 52 and divide by 12, not by 4.
What does the flat-fee model cost on the same sales?
On your own site you pay the payment provider for each card order. Stripe's pricing lists 2.9% + 30 cents for domestic cards. Other providers and countries differ.
Item | Calculation | Cost |
|---|---|---|
Card fee per $50 order | $50 x 2.9% + $0.30 | $1.75 |
Card fees per week | $5,000 x 2.9% + 100 x $0.30 | $175 |
Card fees per year | $175 x 52 | $9,100 |
Software, per year | $59 x 12 | $708 |
Total per year | $9,100 + $708 | $9,808 |
Total per month | $9,808 / 12 | about $817 |
This is why "keep 100% of revenue" is not accurate. Card processing fees from the payment provider still apply. What disappears is the percentage commission on each order.
What is the difference between the two?
If all $5,000 a week moved to direct ordering:
Per month: $5,417 minus $817 leaves about $4,600 saved.
Per year: $65,000 minus $9,808 leaves $55,192 saved.
After card fees, the saving in this example is about $55,000. That is a best case, not a forecast.
What if only some orders move to direct?
Almost no restaurant moves every order. Suppose a quarter of your volume, $1,250 a week, comes through your own site and the other $3,750 stays on the app.
Item (per year) | Calculation | Cost |
|---|---|---|
Commission on app orders | $3,750 x 25% x 52 | $48,750 |
Card fees on direct orders | ($1,250 x 2.9% + 25 x $0.30) x 52 | $2,275 |
Software | $59 x 12 | $708 |
Total | $51,733 | |
Compared with all on the app | $65,000 minus $51,733 | $13,267 saved |
Even a partial shift saves about $1,106 a month here. The more repeat customers you move, the larger the gap.
How many direct orders pay for the subscription?
Per $50 order, an app at 25% costs $12.50. Direct, the card fee is $1.75. Each order you move saves $10.75. A $59 monthly subscription is covered by 6 moved orders (59 / 10.75 = 5.5). Everything after that is saving.
You can run your own numbers in the commission calculator.
How does the result change at 15% or 30% commission?
The 25% rate is one point on DoorDash's range. Here is the same $5,000 a week at each delivery rate, against the all-direct cost of $9,808 a year:
Commission rate | Per week | Per month | Per year | Saving if all moved direct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
15% (Basic) | $750 | $3,250 | $39,000 | $29,192 |
25% (Plus) | $1,250 | about $5,417 | $65,000 | $55,192 |
30% (Premier) | $1,500 | $6,500 | $78,000 | $68,192 |
At 15%, the direct saving per $50 order falls to $5.75 ($7.50 commission minus $1.75 card fee), so the $59 subscription needs about 11 moved orders a month. That is still a small number for a restaurant with regulars. Pickup orders on DoorDash carry 6% commission, which is $3.00 on a $50 order against $1.75 direct, so the gap there is much smaller.
What other costs sit next to commission?
Commission is the visible cost. Three others are easy to miss:
Marketing fees. Sponsored listings and promotions on apps are optional but common, and they come on top of commission.
Menu price markups. Many restaurants charge more on the app to protect their margin. That helps your numbers but can annoy customers who compare prices.
Customer relationships. Direct orders give you the customer's contact details and order history. App orders usually do not, so a repeat customer is always one tap from a competitor.
None of these have a dollar figure in the example above, because they depend on your choices. Add them to your own comparison if they apply.
When is a delivery app still worth it?
Commission buys you something: customers who would not otherwise find you, plus a delivery network. An app can make sense when:
The orders are new sales you would not get otherwise, and they stay profitable after commission and food cost.
You have no drivers and do not want to manage delivery.
You are opening and need visibility fast.
The problem comes when regulars order through the app. They already know you, and you pay a full commission on every repeat order. A common approach is to use apps for discovery and encourage repeat customers to order direct. Check the rules of each app first, as some restrict what you can say to customers in the app itself.
Common mistakes to avoid
Comparing commission with a subscription and ignoring card fees. Direct orders still carry processing fees.
Assuming all orders will move. Plan on a partial shift.
Forgetting menu markups. If you raise prices on the app to cover commission, include that in your numbers, and keep the gap reasonable.
Ignoring app extras. Ads, promotions and tablet fees can add to the real cost.
Using someone else's rates. Rates vary by plan and country. Use your own contract.
How FoodFlick helps
FoodFlick is a commission-free online ordering and POS platform: 0% commission per order and no FoodFlick fees added to your customers' orders. Starter is $59 a month with no setup fee, Professional is $79 a month plus a $149 one-time setup, Enterprise is custom, and annual payment takes 10% off Starter and Professional. Card processing fees from your payment provider still apply, and payments go directly to your provider. Learn more about commission-free online ordering or see the full pricing.
Sources
DoorDash: Merchant fees and pricing, checked November 2026
Stripe: Pricing, checked November 2026
Frequently asked questions
How much commission do delivery apps charge restaurants?
In the US, DoorDash lists Marketplace delivery commission at 15%, 25% or 30% depending on the plan, and 6% on pickup orders. Other apps and countries differ, and extras such as ads or promotions cost more. Always check the platform's current merchant pricing page.
Do I still pay card fees with commission-free ordering?
Yes. Orders paid by card on your own site go through a payment provider, which charges its own fee. Stripe's standard US rate is 2.9% + 30 cents per successful domestic card payment. Cash orders avoid that fee, but you handle the cash.
Is commission-free ordering always cheaper than a delivery app?
Not always. It is cheaper per order, but a delivery app can bring customers who would never find you otherwise. If app orders are genuinely extra sales and profitable after commission, they can be worth keeping. The savings come from moving repeat customers to your own site.
How many direct orders do I need to cover a flat monthly fee?
Compare the subscription with what you save per order. If a $50 order costs $12.50 in 25% commission but $1.75 in card fees direct, you save $10.75 per moved order. A $59 monthly fee is then covered by about six moved orders a month.
Can I use delivery apps and my own ordering site together?
Yes, and many restaurants do. Use apps to reach new customers, and make your own ordering link easy to find on receipts, packaging, social profiles and your Google Business Profile so repeat customers order direct.


